Cozy Fireside Dining in Historic Hunterdon

Hunterdon County is dotted with historic taverns and inns that offer seasonal, farm-to-table meals and cozy fireside dining. The cooler winter months are filled with holiday festivals, charming coffee shops, bundled-up trail hikes, and so much more. And after a long winter day, there’s no better way to warm up than stepping back in time and settling in fireside at one of Hunterdon’s many historic taverns and inns.

Fireside Dining at The Clinton House

The Clinton House was built in 1743 and is filled with historic charm – from its exposed wood beams and large stone fireplace. The fire is always roaring on a cold day, creating a warm atmosphere, literally and figuratively! A full bar and traditional menu provides options for everyone, whether looking for a fabulous steak or a spectacular burger. Located just steps from the Red Mill and downtown Clinton, it is the perfect place to stop and then enjoy the charming Town of Clinton. 

The Inn at Glen Gardner 

Tucked away in the quaint Borough of Glen Gardner sits the historic Inn at Glen Gardner. Enter inside and take in the large stone walls that build this structure nearly 200 years ago. Take a seat and enjoy a comforting meal at a table or sit at the bar and enjoy a bite and a cocktail!

Cree Wine Company

Cree Wine Company in Hampton turns winter evenings into a warm, delicious experience. This inviting wine bar and kitchen offers an excellent selection of wines by the glass, flight, or bottle, alongside a seasonal menu of small plates and shareable dishes. With a relaxed atmosphere and plenty of opportunities to linger over good wine and conversation, Cree Wine Company is a great stop for anyone looking to cozy up during a cold night out in Hunterdon County.

Northridge at Woolverton Inn

Historic Woolverton Inn has begun welcoming more than just hotel guests to dine. Located in a beautifully restored 1830s dairy barn, Northridge’s dining room boasts a striking atrium ceiling, exposed wood beams, and a grand fireplace. Chef Lance Knowling, who previously made his mark at Indigo Smoke in North Jersey, brings his Kansas City-inspired flavors to the menu at Northridge.

Stockton Inn

For a classic fireside dining experience, The Stockton Inn is hard to beat. This historic inn offers a warm, inviting dining room where crackling fireplaces and seasonal American dishes create the perfect winter atmosphere. Ideal for date nights or leisurely dinners, it’s a timeless spot to enjoy great food and a cozy night out.

Tewksbury Inn

Nestled in the village of Oldwick in Tewksbury Township, this historic Tewksbury Inn has been a mainstay of the community since the early 1800’s. Upon stepping inside, you feel as though you could be in a tavern in the English countryside. At first glance you will see exposed beams, wood floors, and even steps upstairs that slope to the side a bit from years and years of feet going up and down them. A menu filled with many classic items and their own specialties, from Filet Mignon au Poivré to Grilled Duck Breast, this is a can’t miss spot to enjoy. Just around the corner is Melick’s Town Farm and Cidery, the Oldwick General Store, and the infamous Julian Gage Antique Shop. 

The Pittstown Inn

“So this is Pittstown!”—the words painted on the barn in the parking lot welcome you to this beloved local spot. Just across the road sits the stone building that houses The Pittstown Inn, offering a classic country-inn feel. Describing itself as a contemporary American restaurant set on tranquil Hunterdon acres, this cozy destination lives up to the name and is perfect for a relaxed winter meal.

The Sergeantsville Inn

Just down the road from Hunterdon’s and New Jersey’s last remaining covered bridge sits the stone walled Sergeantsville Inn. The chef uses local ingredients from local Hunterdon farms and across New Jersey. Maybe you will be lucky and find River Bend Farms Daily Cut or Pecan-Crusted New Jersey Fluke on the menu! The exposed stone walls, beams, and large central fireplace make this a truly classic country inn for every visitor to enjoy.

The Lambertville House

Located in the heart of downtown Lambertville on Bridge Street sits the historic Lambertville House. The restaurant menu is an experience in tastefully small plate selections that offer a delicious array of options for lunch and dinner. Views out the windows of this 1800’s community staple provide glimpses at the many unique shopping options in Lambertville, from clothing to antiques and everything in between. Just a few steps away one can walk onto the bridge and look out at the majestic Delaware River too!

For more dining options check out our full Foodie Fun page here- Restaurants, Breweries, & Wineries in Hunterdon County | Explore Hunterdon County